5th most expensive of 6 Commerce neighborhoods
Cost of Living in Carroll Lake, Commerce
3 homes sold in Carroll Lake in the last 12 months, at a median of $267,500, about $252 a square foot. The median asking rent is $1,650 a month, from 3 homes listed for rent. That ranks Carroll Lake 5th most expensive of 6 Commerce neighborhoods.
- Median sale price
- $267,500
- Price per square foot
- $252
- Median asking rent
- $1,650
- Typical home on the roll
- $254,000
Carroll Lake against Commerce
| Last 12 months | Carroll Lake | Commerce |
|---|---|---|
| Median sale price | $267,500 | $382,500 |
| Price per square foot | $252 | $216 |
| Median asking rent | $1,650 | $1,700 |
| Homes sold (12 months) | 3 | 58 |
Carroll Lake home prices by quarter
-
Q3 2026
$267,500
3 sales ยท $252/sq ft
Homes sold in Carroll Lake
- 290 Vinona Ter, 2 bd $265,000 Sep 2026
- 234 Arabelle St, 3 bd $270,000 Sep 2026
- 5611 Blackmoor St, 3 bd $267,500 Aug 2026
For sale in Carroll Lake now
- 485 W Beechdale St, 3 bd $469,900
- 5687 Carroll Lake Rd, 2 bd $385,000
- 610 Cranbourne St, 4 bd $248,900
- 349 W Beechdale St, 3 bd $244,900
For rent in Carroll Lake now
- 175 Osborne St, 2 bd $1,600 a month
- 6032 Pickbourne St, 3 bd $1,650 a month
- 167 Osborne St, 3 bd $1,900 a month
Neighborhoods priced near Carroll Lake
Keep exploring
- Carroll Lake neighborhood guideHomes, pros, schools and the map
- Commerce cost of living by neighborhoodEvery neighborhood ranked
- Most expensive neighborhoods in CommerceThe last 12 months
- Least expensive neighborhoods in CommerceThe last 12 months
- Cost of living in CommerceThe town against its county and the metro
- Homes for sale in CommerceListings and off-market deals
Carroll Lake cost questions
3 questions
How much does a house cost in Carroll Lake?
Homes in Carroll Lake sold at a median of $267,500 over the last 12 months, from 3 sales, against $382,500 across Commerce.
What is the rent in Carroll Lake?
The median asking rent is $1,650 a month, from 3 homes listed for rent inside the neighborhood.
Where do these numbers come from?
Homes sold, listed and rented through the MLS and Zillow, placed in Carroll Lake by its recorded boundary. Medians, so half sold above and half below.