2026 data · Imlay City
Best Neighborhoods in Imlay City, MI
5 neighborhoods in Imlay City, ranked. Ranked on the county parcel roll: home value counts for half, then home size and how new the homes are. Each one links to its own guide with homes for sale and local pros.
- Ranked
- 5
- Number 1
- Imlay Place
Top 5 best neighborhoods in Imlay City
- 1 Imlay Place Value $250K · 91 homes · ZIP 48444 100 / 100
- 2 Handleys Addition to Imlay City Value $158K · 41 homes · ZIP 48444 75 / 100
- 3 Cooks Addition to Imlay City Value $155K · 50 homes · ZIP 48444 50 / 100
- 4 Hunts Addition to Imlay City Value $153K · 87 homes · ZIP 48444 25 / 100
- 5 Calkins Subdivision Value $151K · 23 homes · ZIP 48444 0 / 100
Keep exploring
More Imlay City neighborhood lists
Across the county
How we ranked these neighborhoods
- Typical home value counts for 50%, typical home size for 25% and the year the typical home was built for 25%.
- Each number is compared with every neighborhood on this page, so 100 is the best on all three here.
- Home value is twice the median assessed value of the houses inside each neighborhood's boundary (Michigan assesses at half of market value), from the Lapeer County parcel roll.
- Neighborhoods with fewer than 5 homes are left out. Police here publish town totals, not each incident's location, so nothing here ranks safety; each town's crime rate page has its numbers.
Questions people ask
4 questions
What is the best neighborhood in Imlay City?
Imlay Place ranks first here: 100 / 100, with about 91 homes. Ranked on the county parcel roll: home value counts for half, then home size and how new the homes are.
What do homes cost in these neighborhoods?
Typical home values here run from $151,000 to $250,000.
Where do these numbers come from?
The Lapeer County parcel roll, for the houses inside each neighborhood's recorded boundary. They are estimates, not appraisals.
How safe is Imlay City?
Imlay City Police Department reported 3.4 violent crimes per 1,000 residents in the 12 months through September 2026. Its police publish town totals, not each incident's location, so neighborhoods here are not ranked on crime. See Imlay City's crime rate page.